14 years, 3762 pages of analyses and hundreds of environmental measures.
Such a large amount of work was involved in one of the most extensive environmental impact assessments (EIA) in Estonia's history, which has now come to an end when the Consumer Protection and Technical Surveillance Authority declared the environmental impact assessment report for the construction project of the Rail Baltica Pärnu–Kabl section to be compliant with the requirements.
This was the last section of the Rail Baltica Estonian main route whose environmental impact assessment was awaiting final approval.
When environmental impact assessments related to Rail Baltica began in 2012, it was believed that the environmental impact of the entire route could be assessed in a single strategic procedure.
The reality turned out to be much more complicated, but the understanding of how detailed the impact of such a large infrastructure project needs to be assessed improved. In the end, the entire main route was analyzed by construction project.
The scope of the environmental impact assessment is also illustrated by its documentation.
The environmental impact assessment reports for the nine main route sections total 3762 pages, excluding appendices. In addition, the appendices contain hundreds of environmental measures that must be taken into account when designing and building the railway.
Environmental impact assessment did not only mean analyzing the impact on nature, but also directly changed the railway project.
For example, ensuring animal movement opportunities in several places determines the height of the railway, and when crossing rivers, the length of bridges to allow animals to move around on the banks. Environmental measures directly affect the cost, technical solutions and construction of the railway.
When designing the route, various natural values had to be taken into account – from wetlands and rivers to Natura 2000 areas and species of the first protection category.
In many places, design solutions were changed, the locations of facilities were specified, and completely new mitigation and compensation measures were developed.
The nearly 45-kilometer-long Pärnu–Kabli section turned out to be the most complicated, as the final location of the route corridor had to be clarified through an updated plan before the environmental impact assessment could be initiated.
The planning also had to assess the impact on the habitats of wild boars in Luitemaa. “In the case of wild boars, the experts came to the conclusion quite quickly that the impact could not simply be mitigated – it had to be compensated. This meant that we had to develop a compensation plan together with experts, the Environmental Board and RMK and find areas where wild boar habitats could be restored. When clear-cutting was carried out in some of these areas in the meantime, some of the work had to be essentially done from scratch,” said Mae.
According to Mae, the most difficult were not individual species, but situations where solving one problem created another: “A good example is fencing a railway. This is necessary for high-speed railways to prevent animals from dying. At the same time, the fence makes the railway a much greater barrier for animals and creates the need to build a passage either under or over the railway. The most difficult part of environmental impact assessment is finding a balance between these conflicting objectives.”
According to Mae, the most important lesson from the entire process was that when assessing environmental impacts, designers should be given clear environmental conditions within which the best technical solution can be found.
"In the first EIA procedures, instead of a substantive requirement, experts often wrote down as an environmental measure the design solution that was on the table at that moment, which they had assessed as suitable, without specifying what the most important criterion for this solution actually was. This is how it happened that when it became necessary to change something in further design, we had to turn to the experts again and clarify the substantive purpose of the measure," said Mae.
"The more experience we gained, the clearer it became that the role of environmental impact assessment is not to determine with every meter of precision where to build something, but to set environmental requirements, which, if met, allow the designer to choose the most reasonable solution. Otherwise, a lot of time is spent on questions about what solutions are equivalent from an environmental point of view, and in the worst case, a situation may arise where even a better solution for the environment is not in line with the EIA measure. This was one of the most important lessons learned in the entire process."
The approval of the environmental impact assessment report for the construction project opens the possibility of starting railway construction on the section from Pärnu to Kabli. Estonia's goal is to be ready to open traffic on Rail Baltica in 2030.
Rail Baltica is a project co-financed by the European Union, which aims to build a modern and environmentally friendly high-speed railway connecting the Baltic States with the rest of Europe. The infrastructure to be built will allow passengers to travel from Tallinn to Riga in 2 hours and 20 minutes and will create the first direct connection on a European standard gauge railway to the port of Muuga. Rail Baltic Estonia is the developer of the Rail Baltica railway in Estonia and will be the future manager of its infrastructure.